Talk:Challenge/@comment-5488450-20130729001423

SPOILERS

Wow, there were so many things about this episode I just loved so so much, and so far, out of all those in Season 5 this is, in my opinions, the best one(which is only four but still with War even two is quite a competition!)!

The first thing which I really enjoyed about this episode was just the toll of Gorsefur. He’s seen this and that and he’s still holding strong-for his squad, for Brookfall for all these cats he loves but then there’s just so much he can do. Eventually, he snaps like he did and that difficulty in making a decision on who to send was just such a blow to the squad and to us as a reader. My poor Gorsy<3

And THE FACT THAT AQUASPLASH MADE AN APPEARANCE IN THIS EPISODE? That just made my day…er my midnight, but you know what I mean. I really do love how you brought her back, though, a character who made a one episode appearance. It’s really similar, I thought, to what you did with Sunstrike-except instead of with an enemy it was with a hero :D I really loved that part though and the end where she was like "Or you'll make me sad too" was just wow.

The cutest part was that encounter with the two EarthClan cats. There are no words to describe just how gorgeous that scene was. EarthClan is not the enemy they are just another side in this war and the she-cat WAS SO FREAKING ADORABLE I REALLY HOPE SHE HAS TO SHOW UP AGAIN<333

And then I like how after that, you just compared them to the other EarthClan squad to show that, yeah, they are not all quite as naive and some EarthClan cats are ready for the war. I also loved how Brookfall took charge for once-she's finally,I'm so curious to see how she'll respond to a bit of pressure for a short period of time!

And ending was another blow, and Oakheart being more hopeful than Brookall liked was just...<3

Can't wait for the next episode :D