User blog comment:Honeyrose34/I'm Thinking About Creating a Wikia.../@comment-1688816-20100911160854/@comment-930988-20100912065108

Yeah, the aging of the cats is quite off. Normally, feral cats (even ones that live in a complex society like a Clan) don't live that long, and most on average die out after 6 or 7 years. But the Erins have some characters that seem to live forever. Ahem, cough cough, Firestar, cough.

ShadowClan was awesome back in the old days, even though I don't think they should be treated as 100% evil. The other three Clans are more evil than ShadowClan a lot of times. I bet it would have been cooler if Brokenstar had stayed around a while longer, instead of the powerful-even-after-death Tigerstar.