Talk:Darkness Around Us/@comment-26136175-20150108130221

STRIKE THAT. I THINK I KNOW THE SECRET.

But so far, I like it's good. Very detailed. I can picture almost every scene in my mind (although the cats are pure white with circles :P), and hear the cats conversing.

Secret Guess: I'm guessing that Pinestar is Ice and Silver's father, and that when he took away his sisters, the sisters were Cherrypaw and Rosepaw. Pinestar (Smoke then) dropped them off at SageClan, and he himself went to HollyClan, where he became leader. That's why he's interested in the rogues.