User blog comment:Cinderstar of ThunderClan/Evil Cats from Warriors/@comment-5259793-20120813021831

Your theory about Thistleclaw is a good one. I'm just one of those people who just doesn't really care for him.

I LOVE TIGERSTAR! It's all Thistleclaw's fault that he was evil, and before Thistleclaw there was Robinfeather. So it's like a legacy of "evil" cats.

I love Mapleshade to. I don't believe she was likeAshfur. Ashfur was a crazy stalker. And if Mapleshade's so much like him, how come he goes to StarClan and she doesn't? Think about it for a sec, will ya?

"Evil" cats are always my fav. Always have been. Always will. :D