Talk:If Spottedleaf had lived/@comment-89.100.216.75-20120527145128

I love this! I still think Ashfur would not have been a better mate to Squirrilflight/star, no offense to anyone who think they would be perfect together. I felt sorry for Ashfur when I heard Squrrilflight telling him what she thought, but I really changed my mind when Ashfur accused Brambleclaw of being like his Father. I felt really angry that he should judge a cat by his/her birth. If he was judgeing Brambleclaw of who his father was, then he was accuseing Squrrielflight of being a kittypet! I still think it was wrong of Hollyleaf to murder Ashfur, but I think Ashfur said and did some pretty bad things himself. 1. He sent his apprentoce to tell Firestar Blackstar was in ThunderClan territory, but Firestar found him in a trap. 2. In a training session he fought with Lionpaw and they fought with claws unsheathed and Lionpaw was bleeding a LOT. 3. He tried to push Hollyleaf, Lionblaze, and Jayfeather over a cliff! 4. He accused Brambleclaw of being like his Father just because he was Tigerclaw's son! But I suppose, evrey cat makes a mistake. I love this, it is amazeing. You should keep writeing warrior cat stories, you are amazeing at them. In fact, this should be in the books!