Talk:Redemption Clause/@comment-5488450-20130726021155

It was one of my original two suspects(the other was Fuzzears), but wow. Even though this was one of my guesses I had not been expecting... wow...

Well there is one thing I loved so much about this episode and that's just the ''guilt. ''Is Lilyshade really guilty or did Shinecloud have it coming? Is it or is it not the right thing to tell SpringClan that Lilyshade was in change for the murder? I mean, you have all these new questions, ethic questions, we can't answer. I mean, I know I compared this to Pretty Little Liars but there, the killer had a motive but it wasn't one that made them any les guilt. Here... you just don't know. And you did such a good job bringing that out.

I thought the Mint statement by Specklepaw was really cute, but there was no Minkpaw in this episode. I personally think the scene with Blackheart could have been stronger if Minkpaw was there too because of her heart and I'd just love to see which side she would go with. Pity for one? Anger at the other? Or both?

And I'm really starting to like Lionwing, btw. Daisypaw was cute in this and that story just broke my heart so much. Duskwatcher is not the cat we thought he was, Lilyshade is not feeling what we thought she was, and Blackheart does not have the reasons we thought he did.

All in all, a marvulous episode! I can't wait to see how you're going to use the next two, now that the killer has already been found :D Also, that rogue was a cool touch. Is it safe to assume he's for Season 2 or do we have more drama ahead of us in the next two episodes?